-
Ziad Ezzat
FAQ
What is all this?
This site is comprised of an email exchange I had with a representative of PicRights.com, a copyright troll company that uses financial threats and pseudo-legal language to scare people into given them money.
Have you ever faced negative consequences for my actions or words?
As of this post’s date, I have still never been contacted by any lawyers, never been sued for copyright infringement, and never given one red cent to the trolls at PicRights. The only thing I’ve heard out of them in years is a couple more of those first contact phishing emails.
While I am not an attorney, I am a creative professional who knows enough about copyright law to have kept myself out of trouble for the past 30 years. If you think you may have violated the law, you should consult an attorney, not some rando on the internet.
But if you’re 100% sure you haven’t done anything wrong, please don’t give these parasites your hard-earned money. Ignore them. Fight them. Troll them back. Waste their time. Just don’t pay them.
And by all means, share your experiences on your own website and social media. I can’t tell you how many people have emailed me over the past few years asking me if this site is real, and trying to find out if I ever got sued or had to pay out.
-
PicRights → AFP
Horse Shit #1
PicRights Ltd. on behalf of Agence France-Presse 3 Concorde Gate, Suite 209 Toronto, ON, Canada M3C 3N7 Telephone: +1 888 367 7778, https://www.picrights.com/
August 14, 2019
Via physical mail and email
Ziad Ezzat , United States
Image License Validation for Agence France-Presse - Reference Number: 3959-2637-3720
Dear Business Owner,
As an introduction, PicRights Ltd. (“PicRights”) provides licensing compliance services to third-party content owners, including Agence France-Presse. Please note that PicRights is not a law firm and I am not a lawyer. PicRights has noticed that imagery represented by Agence France-Presse has been displayed on your website. Agence France-Presse has been unable to find a license for this usage of the imagery by your company. Therefore we are acting on behalf of Agence France-Presse to obtain compensation for your unauthorized past use of their imagery.
At the end of this message, we’ve attached a visual reference of the imagery and its use on your website.
Our goal in contacting you is to ascertain if you hold an active license for this use with Agence France-Presse or with any other entity authorized by Agence France-Presse to license and distribute the imagery:
- If you do have an active license for the use of this imagery, we kindly ask you to send us your valid license / authorization, by visiting https://resolve.picrights.com/395926373720 and clicking the “I have a license…” link; or
- If you do not have an active license for the use of this imagery, we request that you remove the imagery from your website.
- Please be aware that removal of the imagery alone will not resolve this issue. We also require payment of compensation in the amount of $948.00 for the past unauthorized usage of the imagery.
- Please contact us to resolve this matter at +1 888 367 7778 or [email protected] or by visiting: https://resolve.picrights.com/395926373720.
We would like to resolve this time-sensitive issue as soon as possible and request that you respond within 14 days from the date of this correspondence.
If you believe you have received this notice in error or have questions, please contact us with your reference number 3959-2637-3720 at +1 888 367 7778 or [email protected].
On behalf of PicRights and Agence France-Presse, we thank you for your cooperation and look forward to assisting you in resolving this matter.
Sincerely,
Geoff Beal +1 888 367 7778 x2276 Compliance Officer PicRights Ltd. [email protected]
To learn more about PicRights and this specific matter please visit: https://resolve.picrights.com/395926373720. This correspondence is without prejudice to PicRights’s and Agence France-Presse's, rights and remedies, all of which are expressly reserved.
DETAILS
Catalog Image No. AFP_14Y0PT

Proof of use
Page URL: https://ziad.ezzat.com/category/art-and-design/fine-art/Catalog Image No. AFP_15T3N9

Proof of use
Page URL: http://www.ezzat.com/blog -
PicRights → AFP
Horse Shit #2
Confidential/For Settlement Purposes Only Via Email
August 15, 2019
Dear Ziad
Thank you for your email.
The Image is licensed solely for editorial purposes (to inform or illustrate newsworthy events and not to promote products or services) and the primary market for the Image is for educational or informational purposes -- the same purpose as to how your client has used the Image. Based on the same rationale, there would be hardly any market for this Image because it is almost always used for similar reasons as to how you used the Image.
Infringement arises if the whole or a substantial part of an image has been copied. Any use of a manipulated file or derivative work (e.g. cropping, color changes, layering, rotating, etc) without a license from the copyright holder still constitutes copyright infringement. While your company has been using a modified version of the image in question, we believe a substantial part of the original image has been copied.
The image published on your website is a rights-managed image represented exclusively by Agence France-Presse (AFP) and its appointed sub-agents worldwide. The use of rights-managed image represented by Agence France-Presse (AFP) requires a license covering each and every use. By using their copyright-protected image without license or authorization you infringed Agence France-Presse (AFP) copyright and payment of an applicable retroactive license is required to resolve the matter completely.
In order to settle this matter amicably Picrights has reduced the fee by 50% to $474.00. Kindly go to https://resolve.picrights.com/3959-2637-3720 , click on the payment button and follow the instruction to pay via credit card or PayPal. This final reduction will be available to you through (08/25/2019), by which time payment must be received or the offer will be withdrawn.
Under the Question section Click on "Additional Supporting Documents" and you will find a copy of the Settlement agreement and Release, Statement of Authorization, Confirmation of Rights Holdership and Request for Payment.
Should you have any questions please feel free to contact me.
Geoff Beal PicRights T: +1 888 367 7778
-
PicRights → AFP
Horse Shit #3
Confidential/For Settlement Purposes Only Via Email
August 22, 2019
Ref #3959-2637-3720
Dear Ziad
Thanks for your charming email.
We will now be withdrawing our offer and forwarding this matter to our attorneys in the U.S. to proceed with further action.
We reserve all our rights and remedies whether legal or equitable.
Yours truly,
Geoff Beal PicRights T: +1 888 367 7778
-
PicRights → AP
Horse Shit #5
PicRights International Inc. on behalf of Associated Press Hudson Bay Centre 2 Bloor St. East , Suite 3500 Toronto ON M4W 1A8 Canada Telephone: +1 437 887 2292, https://www.picrights.com/
August 10, 2020 Via physical mail and email
Ziad Ezzat Oakland, California United States
Image License Validation for Associated Press - Reference Number: 7688-7532-2397
Dear Ziad Ezzat,
As an introduction, PicRights (“PicRights”) provides licensing compliance services to third-party content owners, including Associated Press. Please note that PicRights is not a law firm and I am not a lawyer.
PicRights has noticed that imagery represented by Associated Press has been displayed on your website: http://www.ezzat.com/. However, Associated Press has been unable to find a license for this usage of the imagery by your organisation. Therefore we are acting on behalf of Associated Press to obtain compensation for your unauthorized past use of their imagery.
At the end of this message, we’ve attached a visual reference of the imagery and its use on your website we are referring to.
Our goal in contacting you is to ascertain if you hold an active license for this use with Associated Press or with any other entity authorized by Associated Press to license and distribute the imagery:
- If you do have an active license for the use of this imagery, we kindly ask you to send us your valid license / authorization, by visiting https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397 and clicking the “I have a license…” link; or
- If you do not have an active license for the use of this imagery, we request that you remove the imagery from your website. Please be aware that removal of the imagery alone will not resolve this issue. We also require payment of compensation in the amount of $1000.00 for the past unauthorized usage of the imagery. You will find further information about this matter along the Remittance payment options by visiting https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397
We would like to resolve this time-sensitive issue as soon as possible and request that you take action within 14 days from the date of this correspondence.
We fully appreciate that this is a very difficult time. With that in mind, we would welcome the opportunity to discuss this matter with you, in the hope that we can achieve a resolution.
If you believe you have received this notice in error or have questions, please contact us with your reference number 7688-7532-2397 at [email protected].
On behalf of PicRights and Associated Press, we thank you for your cooperation and look forward to assisting you in resolving this matter
Sincerely,
Geoff Beal Compliance Officer PicRights International Inc. +1 437 887 2292 [email protected]
To learn more about PicRights and this specific matter please visit: https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397. This correspondence is without prejudice to PicRights’s and Associated Press's, rights and remedies, all of which are expressly reserved.
WARNING: This e-mail message is intended only for the named recipient(s) above and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, subject to copyright and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. You are hereby notified that any unauthorised use of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you are not the named recipient(s), please immediately notify the sender and delete this e-mail message.
DETAILS
Catalog Image No. 18092551966861

Proof of use under http://ziad.ezzat.com/blog/page/5/ Catalog Image No. 16113029171171

Proof of use under http://ziad.ezzat.com/tag/photoshop/page/5/ -
PicRights → AP
Horse Shit #6
PicRights International Inc. on behalf of Associated Press Hudson Bay Centre 2 Bloor St. East , Suite 3500 Toronto ON M4W 1A8 Canada Telephone: +1 437 887 2292, https://www.picrights.com/
December 7, 2020 Via physical mail and email
Ziad Ezzat Oakland, California United States
Unlicensed Use of Associated Press Imagery - Reference Number: 7688-7532-2397 - Ziad Ezzat
If this matter has already been resolved, please disregard this communication.
As an introduction, PicRights (“PicRights”) provides licensing compliance services to third-party content owners, including Associated Press. Please note that PicRights is not a law firm and I am not a lawyer.
You were previously notified of your organization’s unlicensed use of Associated Press's imagery, which is displayed at the end of this correspondence. Copies of our prior correspondence are viewable at the following links for your reference: Sep 23, 2020 https://history.picrights.com/render/HistoryTemplate/30164/YP7V5Q Aug 10, 2020 https://history.picrights.com/render/HistoryTemplate/30164/XT8Q6Q
To date, the matter has not been fully resolved.
Removal of the imagery alone will not satisfy this issue; we require a payment of $1000.00 for past usage of the imagery at issue, even after you have removed the imagery. The payment options are listed at the end of this email.
Unless you contact us or remit the payment within 14 days, we may withdraw the proposed fee and refer this matter to an attorney to pursue other options.
We fully appreciate that this is a very difficult time. With that in mind, we would welcome the opportunity to discuss this matter with you, in the hope that we can achieve a resolution.
To resolve this matter, you can visit https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397 or contact us at [email protected]. Please contact PicRights immediately if you believe you have received this correspondence in error.
Sincerely,
Geoff Beal Compliance Officer PicRights International Inc. +1 437 887 2292 [email protected]
To learn more about PicRights and this specific matter please visit: https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397. This correspondence is without prejudice to PicRights’s and Associated Press's, rights and remedies, all of which are expressly reserved.
“DISCLAIMER: PicRights International Inc. is not a law firm and the compliance officer named above is not a lawyer. You are encouraged to seek independent legal advice with respect to this claim.”
To learn more about PicRights and this specific matter please visit: https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397. This correspondence is without prejudice to PicRights’s and Associated Press's, rights and remedies, all of which are expressly reserved.
WARNING: This e-mail message is intended only for the named recipient(s) above and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, subject to copyright and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. You are hereby notified that any unauthorised use of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you are not the named recipient(s), please immediately notify the sender and delete this e-mail message.
DETAILS
Catalog Image No. 18092551966861

Proof of use under http://ziad.ezzat.com/blog/page/5/ Catalog Image No. 16113029171171

Proof of use under http://ziad.ezzat.com/tag/photoshop/page/5/ Please remit payment by using one of the following payment options:
- Online payment You may remit your payment via credit card or PayPal online at: https://resolve.picrights.com/768875322397
- Bank Transfer payment to:
Bank Name: Royal Bank of Canada Account Name: PICRIGHTS INTERNATIONAL INC. Account #: 05272-4002978 Swift Code: ROYCCAT2 Bank Address: BAYVIEW & BELSIZE, 1554 BAYVIEW AVE. TORONTO, ON M4G 3B6 Intermediary Bank: JP Morgan Chase Swift BIC: CHASUS33 Fedwire ABA/ROUTING #: 021000021 Chips UID: 055253
Please include reference 7688-7532-2397 with wire transfer. U.S. Postal Money Orders are not accepted